Reading Response on Aaron's and Brigid's Reading Responses

I liked and disliked reading Aarons reading response for several reasons. One positive reason that I liked it is I learned a lot about Ranger's Apprentice Book 1. A negative thing that I thought while reading his response was that he gave too much information about the whole story. This disappointed me because after I read all about Sir Rodney and Halt I feel like I already know everything about the book.

I enjoyed Brigid's Reading Response because it left me wanting to read the book A Long Walk to Water. I learned enough things in this reading response to get me interested in reading the book, but not too many things that I feel she gave it all away.